How to lower your experience mod
Your mod comes from three years of claims, payroll and class codes. Some of it you can change this year, and some of it is already fixed. Here's what actually moves the number.
First, know which years count
A mod uses three policy years, ending about a year before the mod takes effect. A mod that starts on January 1, 2027 usually uses the policies that started in 2023, 2024 and 2025. Claims are valued about six months before the mod's effective date.
So the claims you have in your current policy year won't show up until next year's mod, and the oldest year drops off at every renewal. That's the timeline everything below works with.
1. Prevent the small claims, not just the big ones
Each claim is split at the split point. The part below it is primary and counts in full. The part above it is excess, and only a fraction counts. Five $8,000 claims usually hurt your mod more than one $40,000 claim. Safety programs that cut down on cuts, strains and eye injuries pay off directly in the mod.
2. Get injured workers back quickly
In most NCCI states, a claim with medical costs only and no lost-time payments counts at 30% of its value. Once a worker is paid for lost time, the claim counts in full. A light-duty or modified-duty program that brings people back before lost-time benefits start can keep claims medical-only. See medical-only claims and your mod.
3. Report claims right away
Claims reported late tend to cost more: treatment starts later, attorneys get involved more often, and the adjuster has less control. Make reporting the same day the rule, for every injury.
4. Ask for a reserve review before the valuation date
Open claims count at their incurred value: what's been paid plus what the insurer has reserved for the future. If a worker is back on the job but the reserve still assumes months of treatment, the reserve is raising your mod. Ask your agent to request a review of open claims a few months before your claims are valued.
5. Check your payroll and class codes
Your expected losses come from your payroll in each class code. If payroll is under-reported or put in the wrong class, your expected losses are wrong, and so is your mod. Compare the payroll on the worksheet with your audited payroll for each year.
6. Check every claim on the worksheet
Look for claims that aren't yours, duplicates, claims that were closed for less than the amount shown, and claims where money was recovered from a third party. Some corrections can lead to a revised mod. The rules for revisions are narrow, so ask your agent which ones qualify.
7. Know where you stand before the year ends
Your current policy year becomes part of next year's mod. The mod calculator estimates next year's mod and shows how much more in claims this year can take before it goes over 1.00. That tells you how much room you have.
8. Don't let a mod surprise you at bid time
If next year's mod is going above a customer's limit, you'll know months ahead. Use that time to prepare an explanation letter, and to line up work with customers whose limit you still meet.
What doesn't work
- Hiding claims. It's illegal in many states and it puts your coverage at risk.
- Changing insurers. Your mod follows your business, not your policy.
- Opening a new company. Ownership change rules usually carry the old mod over.