What is a good experience mod?
Under 1.00 is good, 1.00 is average, and above 1.00 means your claims cost more than expected for a business like yours. Here's what that means for your premium and for the bids you can win.
The short answer
Your experience mod (also called EMR, e-mod or experience modification factor) compares the workers' comp claims you actually had with the claims a business of your size, in your trades, would be expected to have.
- Below 1.00: your claims were lower than expected. Your premium is discounted. A 0.85 mod takes 15% off the premium the mod applies to.
- 1.00: average. Businesses too small to qualify for a mod are rated at 1.00 too.
- Above 1.00: your claims were higher than expected. A 1.20 mod adds 20%.
Why 1.00 is the number that matters most
For a contractor, the mod is more than a premium adjustment. General contractors, facility owners and public agencies ask for it on prequalification forms and bid packages, usually for each of the last three years. Many of them set a limit, and 1.00 is the most common one. Some ask for lower on high-risk work, and some accept a higher mod if you send a letter explaining it.
That makes the jump from 0.98 to 1.02 more expensive than the premium difference suggests: it can take you off a bid list for a year.
What a mod costs in dollars
The mod multiplies the part of your premium it applies to. If your premium at a 1.00 mod would be $40,000:
| Mod | Premium | Difference from 1.00 |
|---|---|---|
| 0.80 | $32,000 | $8,000 saved |
| 0.90 | $36,000 | $4,000 saved |
| 1.00 | $40,000 | none |
| 1.15 | $46,000 | $6,000 extra |
| 1.30 | $52,000 | $12,000 extra |
And because a mod uses three years of claims, a bad year keeps costing you for three renewals.
Why small companies swing more, and less
Two values on your worksheet control how much your own claims move the mod: the weighting value (W) and the ballast value (B). A small company gets a low W and a large ballast relative to its size, so one big claim can't push its mod sky-high. But several small claims still count in full, because every claim's first part, up to the split point, is counted at full value. For most small contractors, how often claims happen matters more than how big they are.
If your mod is over 1.00
- Check the worksheet for errors. Wrong payroll, a wrong class code, a claim that belongs to another employer, or an open claim whose reserve hasn't been updated. Our worksheet guide shows where to look.
- Find the claims that are doing the damage. The mod calculator shows how much each claim adds.
- Look at next year. The oldest year drops off each renewal. If your worst year is about to fall out, next year's mod may already be headed under 1.00.
- Prepare a letter for customers. Explain what happened and what you changed. Many prequalification reviewers accept a mod above their limit with a good explanation.
More ideas are in how to lower your experience mod.